5 Drowned Men! * Calvin Stymes (Only appearance; dies) * Mister X (Mat Matwell) (Single appearance) * Professor Saul Philpotts (Single appearance) * The Black Rider (Archie Ernder) (Single appearance) * The Grim Marauder (Ed Findley) (Single appearance) * The Wrecker (Ben Stanley) (Single appearance) To revenge himself on five ex-fraternity brothers who traumatized him, Calvin Stymes causes the quintet to be immersed in the waters of Koehaha, which do not drown their victims but instead wash away their consciences. Accordingly, the Justice Society must deal with five brand-new master criminals.